| Platinum | La Rancherita Grill & Tequila Bar of Greenville |
| Gold | Mi Cabana Mexican Restaurant |
| Silver | Chico's |
| Bronze | El Ranchero |
| Top Pick | Anita's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | El Azador |
| Top Pick | La Cabana |
| Top Pick | La Fiesta Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | La Ribera Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Plaza Azteca Mexican Restaurant |