| Platinum | Pirate Auto Sales |
| Gold | Pleasure Ride Auto |
| Silver | Cars and Beyond |
| Bronze | CarMax |
| Top Pick | Bolden |
| Top Pick | Brown & Wood Buick GMC |
| Top Pick | East Carolina Auto Exchange |
| Top Pick | Greenville Auto World |
| Top Pick | Greenville Motor Co |
| Top Pick | Greenville Toyota |