| Platinum | La Casetta Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Nino's Cucina Italiana |
| Silver | Basil's Restaurant & Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Atavola Market Cafe |
| Top Pick | Famiglia |
| Top Pick | Farmville Pizza |
| Top Pick | Luna Pizza Cafe |
| Top Pick | Marabella Old World Pizza |
| Top Pick | Michaelangelo's Pizza on Evans |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |