| Platinum | Farmville Pizza |
| Gold | Cape Fear Seafood |
| Silver | Dixie Queen Seafood Restaurant |
| Bronze | Latin Roots Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | Friday Night Fish Fry |
| Top Pick | Juicy Crab |
| Top Pick | Mayflower Seafood & Grill |
| Top Pick | The Seahorse Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Villa Verde |
| Top Pick | Washington Crab & Seafood Shack |